Screen Gems Movie Reviews
with Kennie Bass. You'll find it First On Fox!

Identity Thief February 8, 2013
Identity Thief
Studio: Universal
Rating: R for sexual content and language

Sandy Bigelow Patterson (Jason Bateman) has a very big problem.

His identity has been stolen and the thief is living it up and ruining his credit.

He lives in Colorado and the local authorities say they aren't going to Florida to nab the culprit.

Sandy travels east to confront the thief named Diana (Melissa McCarthy). He finds his way to her home and gives her the choice about how it's going to go down. She picks the hard way and the battle is on.

Sandy gains the upper hand and proceeds to travel back to Colorado with Diana to clear him name.

But his plan to fly is derailed when she points out they are both using the exact same identification. That means they have to drive cross country. Diana uses that to her advantage, constantly working to get away from Sandy.

"Identity Thief" has a split personality. On one hand, there are plenty of scenes featuring slapstick, physical comedy. Bateman and McCarthy are talented actors who have impeccable timing. There are more than a few laughs as Sandy and Diana spar their way across the U.S.

However, as the movie progresses an underlying serious tone begins to emerge, which doesn't jibe with the overall feel of the story.

It turns out Diana eventually experiences pangs of regret for her misdeeds. I would much rather have seen her continue enjoying her ill-gotten gains without experiencing any remorse. It doesn't ring true for her character.

Plus, the circumstances leading up to Sandy's decision to travel alone to bring Diana to justice are so ridiculous that they pull you out of the story. The filmmakers take the path of least resistance to throw these characters together for their road trip hijinks. I just didn't find it very believable. I realize you sometimes have to stretch reality, but the ineptitude of the authorities here is ridiculous.

The funny parts of the film don't make up for its contrived elements nor the clumsy way everything ties together at the end.

Bateman and McCarthy deserve better material to showcase their skills.

On my rating scale, "Identity Thief" earns a SINGLE..

Screen Gems Score


Motion Picture Association of America

Everything You Always Wanted To Know About The Movie Rating System

The Classification And Rating Administration Movie Rating Search


Tonight at 8:00 PM

Big in the Philippines
The team investigates the death of a country music singer whose remains were found in a shallow grave; Brennan takes a look at Wendall's injuries after he breaks his arm during a hockey game

Get 1/2 price gift certificates

Find us on Facebook